BEST IN CATEGORY 2023
The Deadbolt Mystery Society Monthly Boxby Deadbolt Mystery Society
★★★★★1232
Unbox a mystery! Solve a crime! Close the case! A new standalone mystery every month!
From $23.67$20.12 / box
BEST OF 2023
Finders Seekers Mysteriesby Finders Seekers Mysteries
★★★★★1547
A thrilling mystery game! (without any sensationalized murders) Explore the world solving puzzles & mysteries while collaborating with others!
From $26.40$25.85 / box
BEST NEW BOX 2023
Murder & Co.by Murder & Co
★★★★★4
Intelligent crime solving meets a lifestyle subscription box.
From $60.00 / box
Ships Fast
Enigma Fellowshipby Enigma Fellowship
Intrigue awaits! Unbox fantastic storylines in this escape room-style bimonthly game subscription.
From $20.50$17.08 / box
My Thrill Clubby My Thrill Club!
★★★★☆252
The premium horror, mystery and thriller subscription box. We ship your box in less than 72 hours!
From $18.00$16.50 / box
Free Shipping
The Resystanceby Madmen & Heroes
Disentangle puzzles, ciphers & history-based mysteries.
From $31.50 / box
PREFERRED SELLER
This Whodunit is KILLERby A Killing Affair
★★★★★19
Serial Murder Mystery Game Delivered to Your Door Every Month!
From $32.50$29.79 / box
Ships Fast
The CRAAAFTby Madmen & Heroes
Disentangle puzzles, ciphers & history-based mysteries.
From $31.50 / box
Cryptic Caseby Escape Rooms Monthly
Enjoy a themed AR adventure (plus a cool laser-cut souvenier!) every month.
From $26.50 / box
Puzzle Culture Box (Quarterly Edition)by Puzzle Culture
★★★★★9
Puzzle Culture - puzzling experiences designed for fun, conversation and connection with puzzles and gifts sourced from small businesses and independent artists
From $40.00 / box
PREFERRED SELLER
ForensiKitby ForensiKit by Crime Scene
★★★★★2
Each ForensiKit explores a different technique used in working a crime scene.
From $43.75 / box
PREFERRED SELLER
Sin Cityby A Killing Affair
★★★★★19
Become the Detective in this Riveting Murder Mystery Game!
From $32.50 / box
Challenge your problem-solving skills and have fun with friends and family with a mystery subscription box. These boxes typically include a variety of puzzles, clues, and challenges that must be solved in order to progress through the story and solve the mystery. Do you have what it takes to solve it all?